Choosing the Right 58.19Wh Battery for Your 13-inch MacBook Pro Models
When replacing the battery in your 13-inch MacBook Pro (2016-2022 models), the 5100mAh capacity and 58.19Wh rating are critical specifications that must match Apple's original design. This particular replacement battery claims compatibility across multiple model years (A1708, A2159, A2289, A2338), which requires precise engineering to ensure proper fit and system recognition.
Key Considerations Before Buying
- Verify your exact MacBook Pro model number before purchasing, as the A1708 (2016/2017) and A2338 (2020/2022) have different internal layouts despite sharing battery specifications.
- Check for inclusion of necessary installation tools and adhesive strips, as proper battery adhesion is crucial for safety and preventing movement within the chassis.
- Consider whether the seller provides clear instructions for resetting the System Management Controller (SMC) after installation, which is essential for accurate battery percentage reporting.
What Our Analysts Recommend
Quality third-party MacBook batteries should include authentic-looking connectors that match Apple's proprietary design and mention cycle count compatibility. Look for sellers who specify whether their batteries support macOS battery health management features, as some replacements may trigger persistent warnings despite functioning correctly.
Batteries Market Context
Market Overview
The aftermarket MacBook battery market is crowded with varying quality levels, where 58.19Wh batteries for 13-inch models represent a specific niche requiring precise voltage regulation and communication chip compatibility. Recent improvements in third-party battery technology have narrowed the gap with OEM performance, but consistency remains a challenge.
Common Issues
Many replacement batteries fail to maintain consistent voltage under load, causing unexpected shutdowns despite showing adequate charge. Another frequent problem involves poor calibration with macOS's battery health reporting, leading to inaccurate 'Service Recommended' warnings even with new cells.
Quality Indicators
Reliable manufacturers provide detailed specifications including internal cell chemistry (typically lithium-polymer), charge cycle ratings (usually 500+ cycles), and explicit compatibility statements. Premium replacements often include thermal sensors that properly interface with the MacBook's power management system.
Review Authenticity Insights
Grade B Interpretation
A Grade B authenticity rating with 15% estimated fake reviews suggests generally trustworthy feedback with some manipulation attempts. The 0.31-point drop from the displayed 4.11 to adjusted 3.80 rating indicates inflated positive reviews rather than completely fabricated feedback.
Trust Recommendation
Prioritize reviews from verified purchasers (7 of 9 in this analysis) and pay particular attention to 3-star reviews, which often provide the most balanced assessments of installation challenges and long-term performance. The natural distribution across ratings suggests authentic user experiences.
Tips for Reading Reviews
Focus on reviews mentioning specific installation details like adhesive quality or connector fit rather than generic praise. Look for mentions of battery health percentage after several weeks of use, as initial 'works great' reviews may not reflect long-term cell degradation.
Expert Perspective
This battery's compatibility claim across six different model years (2016-2022) is ambitious and requires careful verification. The 3.80 adjusted rating from authentic reviews suggests satisfactory but not exceptional performance, typical of mid-tier aftermarket batteries. The 5100mAh capacity matching Apple's original specification is positive, but real-world performance will depend on cell quality and power management circuitry. The high percentage of verified purchases (78%) increases confidence in the feedback's reliability.
Purchase Considerations
Weigh the cost savings against potential calibration issues and the technical skill required for installation. Consider whether your specific model (particularly newer A2338 models) might benefit from a more specialized replacement rather than this cross-compatible option. Factor in whether the seller offers support for installation issues, which commonly arise with adhesive removal and connector seating.
Comparing Alternatives
Compare cycle life ratings and warranty terms with other 58.19Wh replacements, as these specifications vary significantly among third-party manufacturers.
