Mrs. Brog Cigar Humidor, Airtight & Durable Waterproof Travel Humidor Case Holds Up to 5 Cigars - Waterproof Humidor Cigar Box
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Review Analysis Results
Analysis Summary
This product shows a moderately high percentage of potentially inauthentic reviews, scoring 42 on the 0-100 scale. The analysis reveals a polarized pattern with 13 verified 5-star reviews (81% of total) alongside concerning indicators. The rating distribution is heavily skewed toward perfect scores, with only two 4-star reviews and one 2-star review breaking the pattern. The verified purchase status of all reviews adds some credibility, but several reviews exhibit formulaic language and lack substantive detail about actual usage.
Specific language patterns raise concerns, including repetitive generic praise like "Very good quality" and "Does the job" without elaboration. Review R2S0DPYWSRT4E9 contains only "Buena calidad" (Spanish for "Good quality") with no additional context. More suspiciously, review R25R7Y5Z58Y5EY appears twice with different content—once as a 4-star review with video metadata that seems like placeholder text, and again as a legitimate 4-star review about a gift purchase. This duplication suggests potential manipulation or technical issues with review submission.
Authenticity indicators show mixed signals. Several reviews demonstrate genuine specificity, such as R1CJ185Q4Q7N9 discussing a rubber gasket issue and fix, or R2RU6OA87R5T82 detailing motorcycle travel use. However, emotional tone often feels exaggerated or promotional, like RJGWORYGHAK5O's "Mrs Brog has done it again with this amazing humidor" and "I am gonna have so much fun with this." The timing pattern isn't visible in this dataset, but the concentration of extremely brief, generic positive reviews alongside detailed negative feedback creates an unnatural distribution.
Key concerns include the duplicate review ID, multiple extremely brief reviews lacking substance, and promotional-sounding language in some 5-star reviews. Positive indicators include the presence of a legitimate 2-star review detailing latch problems, several reviews with specific usage scenarios, and consistent mention of actual product features like foam pads, cigar holders, and humidifier discs. The product appears to be a functional travel humidor with some quality control issues based on genuine feedback.
Key patterns identified in the review analysis include: Extremely brief generic praise, Duplicate review IDs with different content, Promotional/exaggerated emotional language.
Review Statistics
About Review Data Collection
We extract as much review data as Amazon makes available at the time of analysis. The amount may vary due to Amazon's rate limiting, regional restrictions, or other factors. Our analysis is based on the reviews we successfully collected.
Want to analyze more reviews? Install the Null Fake Chrome extension to capture and analyze additional reviews as you browse Amazon.
Free, quick to install, and works on Chrome, Edge, Brave, and other Chromium browsers.
Price Analysis
This Mrs. Brog humidor appears to be a solid mid-range option based on its strong 4.6/5 rating from over 1,500 reviews. Given the typical market range of $15-$80 for travel humidors, look for prices in the $25-$35 range for good value. The high rating suggests good quality for the price category, making it a reasonable choice when priced competitively.
MSRP Assessment
Market Position
Buying Tips
Understanding This Analysis
What does Grade D mean?
This product has significant review authenticity issues. Many reviews show patterns consistent with fake or incentivized reviews. Exercise caution.
Adjusted Rating Explained
The adjusted rating (3.60 stars) represents what we estimate this product's rating would be if fake reviews were removed. This product's adjusted rating is lower than Amazon's displayed rating (4.60 stars), suggesting positive fake reviews may be inflating the score.
How We Detect Fake Reviews
Our AI analyzes multiple factors: language patterns (generic vs. specific), reviewer behavior (history, timing), temporal anomalies (review clusters), verification status, sentiment authenticity, and statistical outliers. No single factor determines a review is fake - we look at the combination of signals.
Important Limitations
No automated system is perfect. Sophisticated fake reviews can evade detection, and some genuine reviews may be incorrectly flagged. Use this analysis as one data point in your purchasing decision, not the only factor. Reading actual review content yourself is always valuable.
