In for Dinner: 101 Delicious, Affordable Recipes to Share

The majority of these reviews for Rosie Kellett's 'In for Dinner' cookbook appear genuine, with approximately 85% showing authentic characteristics. The review set includes 14 total reviews with a mix of verified (V) and unverified (U) purchases, and the overall positive reception aligns with what one would expect for a well-received niche cookbook focused on budget-conscious, communal cooking. The high proportion of 5-star ratings is not inherently suspicious given the specific appeal of this book's concept and the enthusiastic following the author appears to have developed through platforms like Instagram.

Strong evidence of authenticity comes from multiple reviews containing specific personal context and detailed engagement with the book's content. Review #3 discusses how the concept of affordable group meals resonates as a 'lost art' and mentions personally relating to stories in the book. Review #8 shares a specific timeline ('arrived yesterday afternoon') and emotional response ('salivated over'). Review #10 provides concrete evidence of use, stating they've already cooked multiple recipes within a month of publication. These detailed, personal experiences are hallmarks of genuine user feedback rather than manufactured praise.

A few reviews raise minor concerns due to their generic or overly promotional language. Review #2 uses somewhat formulaic praise ('Delicious recipes that use everyday ingredients'), and Review #13 employs marketing-style phrasing ('heartwarming blend of memoir and cookbook—a celebration of food, family, and the memories that tie them together') that reads like jacket copy. Review #14 appears to be an analytical excerpt about 'economy eating' rather than a personal review of the book itself. However, these represent a small minority, and even some of these could be from genuinely enthusiastic readers.

Overall, this appears to be an authentic review set for a specialized cookbook that has found its audience. The presence of both verified and unverified positive reviews, the specific mentions of the author's background and Instagram presence, and the detailed personal experiences described by multiple reviewers outweigh the few generic-sounding reviews. The product seems to genuinely resonate with readers interested in budget-friendly, communal cooking concepts.

Key patterns identified in the review analysis include: Mentions author's communal living/supper club background, Focuses on budget-conscious cooking concept, References Instagram following or author's platform.